I can’t tell you how thrilled I am to share this recipe with you. Eyeliner is one of those things I have tried (and failed to make) many, many times. I tried many times, and ended up tossing a lot of small dishes of darkly coloured muck down the sink. However, I believe I have finally come up with something with which I am happy. Awesome!
The base of this eyeliner is Australian red reef clay. It is highly pigmented, making it perfect for various cosmetic applications. I honestly wasn’t trying to make eyeliner with it—I was experimenting with lip stain, and I realized that the sort of “paint” I made was far more suited to skin that lips. After confirming its compatibility and staying power around the eyes, I set out to make something that was really make-up like.
If you want to be quite reductionist, you can leave out the magnesium stearate (which is for slip) and the guar gum (which is both a thickener and emulsifier). The recipe should still work quite nicely.
Red & Gold Clay Eyeliner
NOTE: I would HIGHLY recommend not making this recipe, and instead use the assorted eyeliner recipes in my book. They are much better, require far fewer weird ingredients, can be made in a full rainbow of colours, and are likely safer as well since these clays are no longer recommended for use in eye cosmetics, though they were when I purchased them.
Add the vegetable glycerin, jojoba oil, and preservative, and mash the mixture together, adding a drop or two of water as needed. Tamp the mixture down into a small cosmetics jar and leave uncapped to dry for a couple days.
To apply, wet a small eyeliner brush and apply like watercolour paint. This goes on more like a gel eyeliner than anything, so you may need to go back to get a strong line.