Today we’re talking about hyaluronic acid! If you haven’t read 2018’s Let’s Talk About Hyaluronic Acid post, definitely give that a read first—it covers the hyaluronic acid basics. In this post I’ll be tackling some of the most common questions I get about hyaluronic acid and highlight some of my favourite hyaluronic acid formulations. Let’s get hydrated!
Post Overview
Hyaluronic acid Q&A
What sort of hyaluronic acid should I buy?
To start with, I recommend purchasing hyaluronic acid that is around 800,000–1 million daltons. Hyaluronic acid of this weight is generally sold as low to medium molecular weight hyaluronic acid, though make sure you check the documentation from your supplier as the named distinctions are not well defined (one supplier’s “low” might be another’s “medium”). This is partially a personal preference thing; I like the silky viscosity of hyaluronic acid of this weight. If you live in a country with great hyaluronic acid availability and you feel like experimenting, go ahead and purchase a variety of weights to see what you like best! According to Simple Skincare Science, “the hyaluronic you want to use should be between 80,000 to 1,000,000 daltons (80 – 1,000 kDa). This seems to be the sweet spot according to studies.”
There is some debate around the usefulness of very high and very low molecular weight hyaluronic acids. The general idea is that within the general 80,000 to 1,000,000 daltons range higher molecular weights work on the surface of the skin, and lower weights can penetrate the stratum corneum to some degree to work more deeply. But, if the molecular weight is much higher than 1 million daltons it won’t do much good, and if it’s much lower than 80,000 daltons, it could cause irritation. LabMuffin has some good discussion of this in this post—definitely give it a read! It’s not quite as simple as high = good, low = bad.
How do I work with hyaluronic acid?
I recommend using the dry powder to create a 1% solution of hyaluronic acid and using that solution in your formulations. I recommend this for two reasons:
- Dry hyaluronic acid can take hours to fully hydrate and dissolve—if you’ve already made the stock you don’t have to wait for it to hydrate every time you make something.
- Hyaluronic acid is effective at low usage rates and it’s much easier to precisely weigh it out when it is in a diluted solution.
How much hyaluronic acid should I use in my formulations?
Around 0.2% is enough (click this link to read more and learn more!). You can use more, but hyaluronic acid is effective at low concentrations and it’s expensive! At ~$5/gram, it’s one of the most expensive ingredients I use. A 100g (3.5oz) batch of a formulation featuring 0.2% hyaluronic acid has about $1 of hyaluronic acid in it! There’s a good chance that is more expensive than the rest of the formulation combined.
To get a final concentration of 0.2% in your formulations you’ll include a 1% stock at 20%. 30% of that 1% stock would be 0.3% hyaluronic acid in the final formulation, etc. You cannot exceed a 1% final hyaluronic acid concentration when working with a 1% hyaluronic acid stock; when you’re working with a diluted solution you can only end up with a lower final concentration than that of the solution.
Studies show that there’s not much benefit including more than 2% hyaluronic acid in formulations (it can actually be counter-productive!).
Why is my 1% stock watery?
If you’ve properly measured everything, differing viscosities of a 1% stock are usually due to using a lower molecular weight of hyaluronic acid (this includes using sodium hyaluronate instead of hyaluronic acid). The higher the molecular weight of the hyaluronic acid, the more viscous a 1% hyaluronic acid solution will be. There’s nothing wrong, and you can still use the stock.
Can I make more than a 1% stock?
It depends; if you’re using a higher molecular weight hyaluronic acid you may encounter issues with it fully hydrating. You can likely make a more concentrated stock with molecular weights below 80,000 daltons.
Is hyaluronic acid vegan?
Yes. The hyaluronic acid we use in our products is made by fermentation and is vegan. Hyaluronic acid does occur naturally in the human body and rooster combs, but cosmetic ingredient manufacturers don’t harvest hyaluronic acid from humans or other living creatures—it would be far more expensive.
Can I use sodium hyaluronate instead?
Generally yes, though remember that its molecular weight is very low so it will not make a viscous solution and will perform differently than a higher weight hyaluronic acid.
(Sodium hyaluronate is the sodium salt of hyaluronic acid.)
What else can I use instead?
You’ll want to look at other humectants like glycerin, propanediol, and sodium lactate. The specific formulation and your personal tastes will both factor into determining what the best option is.
Relevant links & further reading
- Hyaluronic acid in the Humblebee & Me Encyclopedia
- Let’s Talk About Hyaluronic Acid
- Hyaluronic Acid for Skin Explained (25 Studies): EVERYTHING You Need to Know! from Simple Skincare Science
- What is hyaluronic acid and how does it work in skincare and makeup? from Lab Muffin
Ten Projects to Make with Hyaluronic Acid
Start with a simple 1% hyaluronic acid stock. It’s the starting point for all of my hyaluronic acid formulations.
You can use that stock as it is, or you can upgrade to a Lavender Aloe Hydrating Facial Toner, including some lavender hydrosol and other skin goodies like allantoin and panthenol.
If you’d like something with a more serum-y consistency, check out my Hyaluronic Acid B5 Facial Serum. A touch of xanthan gum gives this serum more body than the lavender toner, and some PEG-8 dimethicone adds some lovely slip and richness.
For a lovely facial lotion, try my Sugar Plum Facial Lotion. Soothing panthenol, brightening N-Acetyl Glucosamine, and luxurious argan oil team up with hyaluronic acid for a downright swoon-worthy formulation.
For a more targeted product, try my Prickly Pear Eye Gel Cream. Hyaluronic acid helps plump fine lines while caffeine powder helps de-puff the under-eye area.
My Brightening Gel Serum combines hyaluronic acid with niacinamide (Vitamin B3) and N-Acetyl Glucosamine for a luxurious serum that both brightens and moisturizes the skin.
Want to seriously pamper your hands? Try my Pemberley Hand Lotion. It was my Formula Botanica Diploma in Organic Skincare Formulation final project, and it’s utterly lovely.
For some body-pampering goodness, try my Strawberry Rose Body Glow Serum. It’s scented with strawberry and rose hydrosols for a delicious skin treat.
For even more all-body awesomeness, my ultralight Strawberry Kiwi Body Yogurt is just the thing for anyone who prefers their skincare products to be featherlight.
Looking for an indulgent masking experience? My Herbs & Honey Pink Clay Mask was inspired by a face mask I spotted on Instagram that rings it at about $100/100mL—and it’s nowhere close to $100 to make your own!
Hi Marie
I’m really thankful for your blog,
You are awesome
Question please
Do you have any formula for stretch marks? Thank you
Hi Amelia! If the stretch marks are already there I think the best thing you can do without more serious interventions would be keeping the area well moisturized and waiting for them to fade on their own. If you’re looking for a more drastic approach you might consider micro-needling; I remember seeing some good results from people on reddit 🙂
Thank you! Can you please tell me what is a good moisturizing oil/ Butter or a formula
Hi Amelia! I don’t know if you’d be interested in this or not, it’s not from “our lovely Marie,” but I have made this particular stretch mark recipe for several mommy’s to be as a gift & they said it worked wonders & their s-marks were barely to non-existant! I even use this for my very dry skin & it is wonderful. I think Marie has the key that she mentioned to you, keep the area well moisturized, especially if they’re already existing!! This stuff seems to help do the trick. It may not take them away, but it may help lessen visible evidence. Give it a try!
https://naturalbeautyworkshop.com/my_weblog/2017/03/happy-mama-belly-balm.html
Who knows, maybe Marie can morph this into something else! 🙂
All of the ones linked here in this post are great! For anhydrous products, look here. This formulation was designed specifically as a belly bar 🙂 Happy making!
I want to try out Lotion Crafters HA 4D that has different weights. Has anyone tried this one yet?
Hi Leslie! I wanted to try that out too! So I actually purchased it but I haven’t had time to use it yet. I plan on working it into a face cream I make when I get back from a trip in Mid-May. If you get to purchasing it & incorporating it in a recipe before I do, let me know what you think! 🙂
Every place that currently sells Hyaluronic Acid, is actually selling you Sodium Hyaluronate. If you look closely, you’ll see that you are not getting true Hyaluronic Acid, they only like to market it as such.
When I inquired about this, the suppliers responded with:
“Once added to water, the sodium ion dissociates from the salt and hyaluronic acid is formed. This raw material is more shelf stable when supplied as an anhydrous powder and is the industry standard.”
Thanks so much for this! I’ve been wondering what to do with my HA. I forgot I’d made a 1% stock and when I had a breakout due to some medicine, started just applying it directly. Anyway, it worked out and I’m back to my normal skin, but I’ve been thinking I should probably use this. Thanks again!
Sorry, I realised that was poorly written, by “applying it directly” I’m referring to the stock. I’d found it and figured I should try. I was definitely not applying the incredibly expensive powder directly to my face, haha.
So when using the HA solution, you should use anywhere between 20% to 30% of the stock in a formulation?
Hi! I bought some hyalurosome from a well known supplier thinking it was HA, and it is, but it’s not in the powdered form I’ve read about in different places on the internet. Can you help me understand how I use it in, say, a dropper bottle facial serum oil? its quite viscous like a watery lotion. Any help is much appreciated!!!