This is an experiment I’ve been meaning to conduct for ages. For as many DIY concoctions I’ve made over the years, I still found myself wondering how much beeswax to add to something to get a certain level of hardness or thickening. So, one short winter day I set out to settle that once and for all, and here’s what I learned.

14-02-09-pic01

I started with eight little stainless steel bowls with ratios noted on the side—1:1 through 1:8. The “one” was always beeswax, the second number olive oil. As always, I worked in weight, using a unit of 1 gram. So, 1:1 was 1 gram of beeswax and 1 gram of olive oil. 1:4 was 1 gram of beeswax and 4 grams of olive oil.

14-02-09-pic02
14-02-09-pic03

I melted each little pot of beeswax and oil together using a double boiler, and let them all harden for several days (because the weekend ended and I had to go back to work, haha). I did everything in my house during the winter, with an average ambient temperature of about 20°C. So, if you live somewhere drastically warmer than I do, you will likely find these observations a little on the harder side.

14-02-09-pic04
14-02-09-pic05

Now, for my observations. Here’s what I was looking at:

  1. How hard was it? I tested this by pressing on the surface of the mixture with my fingertip (as you would to apply a salve or lip balm), and then scraping with a fingernail.
  2. How quickly did it melt? This was pretty easy to observe by simply handling bits of each mixture.
  3. How sticky was it? I rubbed the mixtures into my arm and tested to see how tacky they were.
  4. How was the slip? I tested this by rubbing bits of the mixture on my lips as they are more sensitive than my arm, and also very familiar with lip balm.

14-02-09-pic07
14-02-09-pic08
14-02-09-pic09

Here’s what I noticed:

14-02-09-pic10
14-02-09-pic11

1:1—Equal parts beeswax and olive oil yielded a very hard mixture. I could not push through it with my finger, and it didn’t start to melt at all as I tried. I was able to scrape it up with my finger nail. When handled, it was quite tacky/sticky and hard, with terrible slip (it skidded) and a high melting point.

14-02-09-pic12
14-02-09-pic13

1:2—I still could not push a finger through the surface. Sticky, poor slip, high melting point.

14-02-09-pic14
14-02-09-pic15
14-02-09-pic16

1:3—I could make a dent in this one with my finger, though it took quite a bit of effort. It’s wasn’t sticky (nothing from here out is), but still too hard for a salve. This one was body butter bar territory, or perhaps a harder lip balm for hot climates.

14-02-09-pic17
14-02-09-pic18

1:4—I could easily press my finger through this one, and it melted on contact with the skin. Good slip, not sticky. This one would be good for a hard salve. This is also the last decidedly solid one.

14-02-09-pic19
14-02-09-pic20
14-02-09-pic21

1:5—Quite soft—this is the first one that gives to finger pressure without the mixture cracking. This ratio makes a nice soft salve. Melts quickly on contact with the skin. Good slip, not sticky.

14-02-09-pic22
14-02-09-pic23
14-02-09-pic24

1:6—Very soft, though the beeswax seems to have floated to the top a bit on this one as it is hard on the surface, but soft underneath. Melts quickly.

14-02-09-pic25
14-02-09-pic26
14-02-09-pic27

1:7—I stopped noticing big differences around this point. Again, very soft, melts quickly, absorbs easily.

14-02-09-pic29
14-02-09-pic30

1:8—Melts almost instantly on contact with skin, very soft. It’s about the consistency of thick lip gloss.

14-02-09-pic31
14-02-09-pic34

So, lessons learned:

  • 1:1 and 1:2 are pretty much useless for skincare, so avoid recipes that use more than 33% or so beeswax, and don’t try to “save” something by adding boatloads of beeswax
  • Use 1:3–1:5 for most salves and balms
  • After about 1:6 you’re just thickening to varying degrees
Hard? Solid? Melt speed Sticky? Slip
1:1 Very Yes None Yes Terrible
1:2 Very Yes None Yes Terrible
1:3 Firm Yes Slow Not really OK
1:4 No Yes Average No Good
1:5 No No Average No Good
1:6 No No Fast No Good
1:7 No No Fast No Good
1:8 No No Very fast No Good

Did you enjoy this post? Take a second to support Humblebee & Me on Patreon!

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This

Subscribe and get my FREE DIY Skin Care for Beginners course!

New to DIY? Subscribe to my mailing list to get exclusive access to my free DIY Skin Care for Beginners course! You'll get a shopping guide and six carefully developed recipes, complete with PDF downloads and video guides, to help you dive into DIY skin care.

Thanks so much—you're on the list! You'll get your first email any minute now :)